Skip to main content

Thoughts From Bible Study Magazine

Dear Friends,

Today’s related “thoughts” are for those who are a bit more inquisitive. For those who like to do more than just scratch the surface. For those who enjoy trying to figure out a puzzle. So, yes, I know they are not for everyone. But I do wish everyone would take the time to read them over! After all, if nothing else, it would help you understand what your pastor goes through every Sunday when trying to put together a sermon!

Both entries come from, “Bible Study Magazine” (Logos, Nov. / Dec. 2022, Vol. 15, No. 1) which I received (unsolicited) in the mail today. The first selection is entitled, What was Paul’s “Thorn in the Flesh?” by Murray J. Harris. The second is entitled, How To Deal with Inspired Ambiguities in the New Testament, by Nathaniel J. Erickson. They are both excellent articles which I only cite in part - meaning that if you want to look at the complete articles (and other helpful ones as well) you will need to get a copy of your own! Enjoy.

Just to set the stage for the first, II Corinthians 12:5 says: “And because of the extraordinary nature of the revelations, therefore, to keep me from being too elated, there was given me a thorn in the flesh, a messenger of Satan sent to pummel me, to keep me from being too elated (or conceited).”


“... From 2 Cor 12:7-10 we may deduce that this “thorn” had certain characteristics.

1. It was given to Paul as a direct consequence of the revelations he received in paradise (v. 7).
2. It caused him acute pain, either physically or psychologically, which prompted him to seek its removal (vv. 7-8).
3. He regarded it, paradoxically, as simultaneously given by God (“was given” is a “theological passive”) and yet a “messenger” or instrument of Satan.
4. It was a permanent condition, as implied by the two present tenses, “to keep me from being too elated” and “to pummel.” Yet its exacerbations were intermittent, as implied by the “three times (I implored the Lord)” in verse 9.
5. It was humbling, for it was designed to curb or prevent spiritual arrogance (“to keep me from being too elated”) over the “extraordinary nature” … of the revelations received.
6. It was humiliating, comparable to receiving vicious blows about the face.
7. It caused Paul to feel weak (vv. 9-10), yet the weakness it caused became an object of boasting (v. 9) and a source of pleasure (v. 10).


Proposed identifications of the “thorn,” legion in number, can be classified under three main headings: spiritual or psychological anxiety; opposition to Paul in general or at Corinth in particular; or a physical malady, often unspecified but sometimes identified as malaria or defective vision.

Some kind of physical ailment most easily accommodates the seven characteristics of the “thorn” outlined above. In 1 Corinthians 5:5 (cf. 1 Cor 11:30; 1 Tim 1:20), Satan appears as God’s agent for the infliction of disciplinary illness (cf. Job 2:1-10). Certainly, a recurrent and tormenting illness could be considered “a messenger of Satan,” for it might bring Paul within the shadow of death (cf. 2 Cor 1:8-9) or hinder the advance of the gospel either by arousing the contempt of the hearers (cf. Gal 4:13-14) or by frustrating his travel plans (cf. 1 Thess. 2:18). Be that as it may, behind any and every machination of Satan, Paul could discern the overarching providence of a God who perpetually creates good out of evil.


If Paul had identified his “thorn” [if he had been precise] Christians of subsequent generations who lacked his particular affliction would have been tempted to regard his experience, as summarized in 2 Corinthians 12:8-10, as largely irrelevant to their situation. As it is, multitudes of believers with a variety of “thorns” have been challenged and consoled as they have made Paul’s experience their own.”

“The Exciting World of Circumstantial Participles"
We need to start by talking about something most people are blessed to give little attention to: circumstantial (adverbial) participles in Koine Greek. [The Greek which the New Testament was written in.] (Have patience, this will pay off!) The label indicates what these verb forms do: they describe the circumstances in which the action to the main verb takes place.

A.T. Robertson, the great Baptist grammarian, says that circumstantial participles are ‘inherently imprecise.’ Matthew 28:19 affords one famous example of this imprecision. Consider the difference in the way the following two translations of the beginning of the Great Commission run:

“Therefore, as you go, disciple people in all the nations.” (ISV)
“Therefore, go and make disciples of all nations.” (NIV)

In Greek, the word translated “go” is one of these circumstantial participles. Painfully it is literally, “Going, make disciples.” The main verb in verse 19 is the command, “disciple” (ISV) or “make disciples” (NIV). According to the ISV, the command here is to make disciples “while going about (normal) life.” According to the NIV, the command is to, “go and make disciples.”

For reasons beyond the scope of this article, most translations go with the NIV’s option here. They translate the Greek participle “going” as a command: “Go!” But that doesn’t mean the ISV is wrong; the Greek circumstantial participle makes the ISV reading equally possible. The (never-ending) debate is over which meaning is more probable, given the context. In a definite sense, God gave us this debate. The text is not spiritually deficient for having a degree of ambiguity. Jesus spoke with purposeful imprecision, and he used a common imprecision in Greek grammar to do it.

Far more could be said about Greek participles – or many other facets of Greek grammar – but this example eloquently sums up the difficulty in treating them: Greek participles are a choice by the writer/speaker to be less precise rather than more precise.”


What does chosen or 'divinely inspired imprecision' on the part of biblical authors do for us? Many things! It helps us approach certain texts with more humility when we discuss their meaning and application to life. It also drives us to do more research and thus learn a lot more about the text than we would if it were all ‘very precise’ or ‘black and white.’ It also helps us see why there are very justifiable variations between the English translations in regard to certain texts. And likewise, it leaves needed room for changing methods in changing cultures when we proclaim the unchanging message of Scripture. It does good things for us, Christ's Church in general, and its mission in this world!

As we Grow in the Grace and Knowledge of Jesus, Pastor Jeff

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Thoughts In Memory of Tim Keller

Dear Friends, News broke last Friday (May 19) that pastor Tim Keller had gone home to be with Jesus. I must say that his commitment to a gospel-centered understanding and application of Scripture, his determination to reach this generation, his encouragement to live out the Gospel through our lives and words and actions, his keen insights into contemporary culture, and his gracious way of engaging even with those he disagreed with – have been an inspiration to me and multitudes of others. He was truly a gift of God to many pastors and parishioners in our day. Therefore, today, in honor of his life and ministry, I offer you a mere sampling of 20 Tim Keller quotes. But I warn you that although reading Keller can be insightful and refreshing, it can also be a bit convicting and unsettling. Through his insights you will learn to see old things in a new light (which stirs the spirit!), but you will also discover that you do some of what you do for reasons other than what you had th

Thoughts From Priscilla Shirer

Dear Friends, During difficult times have you ever been tempted to focus only on the negative, the lack, the struggle, the sense of hopelessness? And if you were tempted to do so, did it blind you to what you did have? Did it cause you to overlook the blessings that were there all along, even in the midst of those times of lack? It’s not hard to do so. Our mounting concerns during difficult times can blind us to God’s supply. This week’s “thought” speaks to that situation. It comes from the devotional book entitled “Awaken” by Priscilla Shirer. A friend gave it to me a couple weeks back and I’m just starting to go through it. This particular devotion is entitled “What Do You Have?” and is based on II Kings 4:2 where a widow owes money, is confronted by creditors who come and threaten to take her two sons and sell them into slavery, in order to cover her debt. When Elisha finds out, he asks her: “What can I do for you? Tell me, what do you have in your house?” Priscilla’s

Thoughts From Horatio Spafford

Dear Friends, I like stories. True stories. And not always stories that have a happy ending. In fact, I have gained much solace from stories that were very sad (like this one), but were helpful because they were about real people, struggling with raw emotions, and real issues, in an imperfect and fallen world where our ultimate hope must rest elsewhere. This morning I read a story I've read before. It's one I have even shared from the pulpit before. And I know that many of you (like me) have already heard as well. But then I thought, "Maybe some do not know it." And if you happen to be one, you need to read on! I pass this story along for you. For those who have not heard the story behind the writing of the hymn, "It Is Well With My Soul" by Horatio Spafford. Because once you know the story behind it, it's hard to ever sing it again in the same way. And even if you already know it, it is always helpful to pause and think once again about a